Black Labrador Retriever outdoors at Hunters Creek Retrievers

I want to tell you about a veterinarian who stood in front of a camera and did something almost no professional ever does. Dr. Karen Becker, an integrative wellness veterinarian who has spent her whole career studying why dogs get sick, looked back on the thousands of young patients she had spayed and neutered early in her practice, and she apologized. In her own words: "I started apologizing to my clients, and I apologized to my patients as well." She wasn't apologizing for a botched surgery or a bad diagnosis. She was apologizing for following the standard advice, the very same advice most of us grew up believing was simply the responsible thing to do.

That took courage, and it's worth understanding why she said it.

A Veterinarian's Change of Heart

When Dr. Becker first opened her animal hospital, she was so adamant about spaying and neutering before a dog's first heat cycle that, by her own admission, if a client didn't follow her advice she "really became upset," and she'd suggest they might be more comfortable finding another veterinarian. So she desexed thousands of her patients while they were still very, very young, convinced she was doing the right and ethical thing.

Then, about five years in, her patients started developing endocrine problems, even though these were dogs eating fresh, biologically appropriate diets and weren't over-vaccinated. That didn't add up, so she went looking for answers, tracing a thread from adrenal disease in ferrets desexed at three weeks of age all the way to a spike in canine hypothyroidism she was seeing in 2006. The conclusion hit her, as she put it, like a lightning bolt: for years she had been making her recommendation "not based on what was physiologically best for my patients, rather what I felt was morally best for the owners."

Here is the part that stays with you. She said, plainly, "I cried in my exam rooms from 2006 to 2010 more than I have ever cried in my adult life," because so many of the dogs she had desexed early were cycling back through her practice with irreversible metabolic disease. Her guiding conviction now is common sense to any breeder who has watched a lot of dogs grow up: "removing any organ, and certainly all the organs of reproduction, will have health consequences; it's inevitable."

What the Research Actually Shows

Dr. Becker didn't change her mind on feelings. She changed it on a stack of studies, and the numbers are hard to ignore:

  1. A 2009 Rottweiler study from the Gerald P. Murphy Cancer Foundation found that females who kept their ovaries until at least six (6) years of age were four (4) times more likely to reach an exceptional old age than those spayed young.
  2. In a review of dogs with tumors of the heart, spayed females carried over four (4) times the risk of intact females, and for hemangiosarcoma, the most common cardiac tumor, spayed females showed a greater than five (5) times risk.
  3. In another Rottweiler study, dogs spayed or neutered before one (1) year of age faced a one-in-four (1-in-4) lifetime risk of bone cancer, significantly higher than intact dogs.
  4. A Texas Tech study on cranial cruciate ligament injuries concluded that spayed and neutered dogs of all breeds and sizes ruptured that ligament at significantly higher rates than their intact counterparts, and a Cornell study tied early sterilization to a greater likelihood of hip dysplasia.
  5. A University of California, Davis study of several hundred Golden Retrievers found the rates of hip dysplasia, cruciate tears, lymphosarcoma, hemangiosarcoma, and mast cell tumors all ran significantly higher in the neutered and spayed dogs than in the intact ones.

Add early-spay urinary incontinence and a higher rate of infectious disease in shelter dogs desexed before twenty-four (24) weeks, and you begin to see why a thoughtful veterinarian would stop treating "fix them at six months" as gospel.

A Fence Is Not Birth Control

Now, none of this means turning intact dogs loose on the neighborhood. Read that twice, because it's the whole point. The reason we spay and neuter in this country isn't really the individual dog's health at all; it's generations of irresponsible owners and millions of unwanted puppies. Dr. Becker is blunt about that, and so am I: an irresponsible owner absolutely needs a sterilized pet.

The good news is that responsibility, not surgery, is what actually prevents unwanted litters. Dr. Becker points to European countries where intact dogs move through daily life under voice and leash control, and to a British veterinarian who, when Americans living in London ask him to neuter their dog, simply asks how a dog that is always leashed and always supervised would ever manage to get pregnant. Her one warning is the same one I give every family, especially with a male: supervision has to be real. As she says, "it doesn't matter if you have a fenced-in yard if there's an unsupervised intact male around; there's absolutely a risk of impregnation through the fence."

That's exactly why I recommend a full six-foot (6 ft) fence for a Labrador and why I train the owner as hard as I train the dog. A Lab is an athlete who can clear a four-foot (4 ft) fence like it isn't there, so a short fence or a distracted afternoon is not a birth-control plan. Constant supervision, a leash you actually control, and obedience that holds under drive are the plan. Get those right, and the surgery becomes a real choice instead of a reflex.

Where Hunters Creek Stands

At Hunters Creek Retrievers, we don't require you to spay or neuter your puppy. We control breeding the honest way, through limited AKC registration and co-ownership for anyone who wants breeding rights, so we can place a pup in a committed, well-supervised home and still trust the timing decision to you and your veterinarian. We'd rather spend that energy teaching you and your whole family to manage and handle your dog, because a dog under control is a dog that never needs a fence to keep it safe.

Dr. Becker's bottom line is one I share word for word: "The decision to sterilize, spay, or neuter your pet, and at what age, and with what technique, is a very personal decision that is based on your dog's breed, temperament, personality, and your commitment to training, lifestyle management, and responsibility."

Make that decision with the facts in front of you, not out of habit, and make it with a veterinarian who knows your dog. If you'd like to talk it through, or you want a dog trained so well that supervision is second nature, call me anytime — that conversation is exactly what we're here for.

Watch & Learn

Dr. Karen Becker — "The Truth About Spaying and Neutering"

Watch on Facebook

Keep reading: Canine Lymphoma: What Tucker Budzyn’s Death Can Teach Dog Owners

Sources

[1] Dr. Karen Becker, "The Truth About Spaying and Neutering" (video and article), drkarenbecker.com

[2] University of California, Davis — "Neutering health effects more severe for golden retrievers than Labradors" — UC Davis

[3] Hart et al., PLOS ONE — "Long-Term Health Effects of Neutering Dogs: Comparison of Labrador Retrievers with Golden Retrievers" — PLOS ONE

This article is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for veterinary advice. Spay and neuter decisions should be made together with your veterinarian. Statistics are as presented by Dr. Karen Becker from the studies she cites.