Home / Training / E-Collar Training
Top Dog Training USA · E-Collar Training

E-Collars Can Save Your Dog's Life

E-collar training, start to finish — and the five things where you say nothing at all.

A yellow pup named Gus made it eleven months. Eleven good months — house-trained, crated, sat for his supper, slept on a girl's bed. Then a UPS truck came down the county road, the storm door was open four inches, and the whole eleven months went out that gap in about a second and a half. His people did everything right except the one thing that would have mattered. They had taught that dog to obey a voice. Nobody had ever taught him to obey a voice he could not hear.

That gap — between where your voice ends and where your dog goes — is the whole subject of this page. There is exactly one tool that closes it, and it is the most slandered piece of equipment in the dog world.

Start with the name, because the name is a lie

Call it a shock collar and you have already lost the argument, because the picture that word paints has nothing to do with the thing sitting on my truck seat. Nobody is electrocuting anything. The right name is remote collar, and the technology is the same thing your chiropractor hooks to your lower back: a TENS unit — transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation — a low-voltage pulse that talks to nerve and muscle right where the pads sit.1 Grandma gets one on her shoulder at physical therapy and calls it a blessing. Put the identical technology on a Labrador and half the internet calls it torture.

Here is what I do with a doubter, and I have done it a few hundred times. I hand them the transmitter, tell them to press the two contact points into their own palm, and I walk the dial up from the bottom. At the levels we actually train on, most grown adults feel nothing at all for the first several settings. When they finally do feel something, they describe a tingle, a bug walking across the skin, a little muscle twitch.2 Ed Frawley calls it “more of a tingling feeling which most dogs just ignore.”3 Not one person has ever handed the transmitter back and said it hurt. Not one.

The collar earned its bad name honestly, though, and I will say so. It got that name from people who bought one on a Tuesday, strapped it on a dog on a Wednesday, and started mashing buttons with no more idea of what they were doing than a chimpanzee with a chainsaw. That is not the collar. That is the man. A hammer builds a house or it smashes a thumb, and nobody blames the hammer.

The gear, and why the cheap one costs you more

Buy a quality unit or do not buy one at all. A twenty-nine-dollar box off a marketplace with no brand name delivers whatever voltage it feels like delivering that morning, which is precisely how dogs get frightened and how this tool got its reputation. The one I hand most clients is the Dogtra 280C: a rheostat dial with 0 to 127 stimulation levels so you can split hairs on a sensitive dog, a half-mile range, nick and constant and a separate high-performance pager vibration with no stimulation in it whatsoever, waterproof to IPX9K, and a receiver small enough for a ten-pound dog.4 The Dogtra ARC and the 1900S are the other two I recommend, depending on the dog and the hand holding the transmitter.

One hundred twenty-seven levels sounds like overkill until you have worked a soft dog. On a fine dial you can find the exact rung on the ladder where a dog notices and nothing more. On a cheap eight-level unit, level two is nothing and level three is a rodeo.

Prerequisites — the collar goes on last, not first

Nobody straps a remote collar on a green dog and starts pushing buttons. The collar does not teach. It reminds. Before the receiver ever touches a neck, the dog must already own his foundation on a leash and a check cord:

  • Engagement — the dog looks to you and wants to be with you.
  • Come — food at the nose, back up, hand to the belly, the dog follows the lure without a fight.
  • Sit — clean, easy, no wrestling.
  • Down — food to the ground, the dog folds.
  • Stay — the beginnings of it. He holds a beat.
  • Loose-leash heel — head and shoulder at your left leg, slack in the line.5

If the dog does not know a command cold on a rope at six feet, the collar cannot help him remember it at sixty yards. You are not teaching him anything at that point. You are just confusing him at a distance, which is exactly what the critics accuse us of, and in that one case they are right.

The report card — where your dog actually stands

Garrett Wing and the DIY K9 crew have a progress chart they call the FHVLE, and it is the cleanest picture of this whole business I have run across, so I will give them the credit and use it.11 Every command your dog knows gets graded across five columns:

FFood
HHand
VVoice
LLeash
EE-collar

A dog who will sit in the kitchen for a bite of cheese has one check mark, and that is an F. A dog with food, hand, and voice is a C-minus. Add the leash and you have a B-plus. The A-plus is off leash in the real world, with distractions, no treats in your pocket and nothing in your hand.

Two more rules worth writing on the wall: do not name it until you love it and new before known. You also want three words nailed down before you start: Yes, Good, and No.

Fit — the number one reason e-collars “do not work”

When a client calls me and says the collar is not working, it is one of three things almost every time. The collar was never charged. The collar was never fitted. Or the man never conditioned the dog to it. Fit is the big one.

  • Receiver rides on the side of the neck, high, not dangling under the throat.
  • You should get one finger under the strap. Not two, not none.
  • The collar should move a little with the skin, not slide around the neck like a hula hoop.
  • Match the contact points to the coat.
  • Charge it every session. A dying battery lies to you.

Take it off, too. A remote collar is training equipment, not jewelry. Sustained pressure from the strap and the points can cause pressure sores. My rule is simpler: the session ends, the collar comes off.6

Step One
Teach the pager to mean COME

The vibration goes first, and it has no stimulation in it at all. It is a tap on the shoulder from four hundred yards.

Make the buzz the best news of his day. Push the pager, hand him a treat. Push, treat. Push, treat. Once he loves the buzz, pair it with Come, then start dropping the word until the pager means come all by itself. The same buzz can give a deaf dog off-leash communication he could never get from a voice.

Step Two
Find his working level, one rung at a time

Never pick a number. Let the dog pick it. Start low and climb one rung at a time looking for the first small sign that he noticed: an ear twitch, head turn, glance at the ground, or sudden sniff. There should be no yelp, jump, or drama. If there is, you went past his level.7

The working level is a floor, not a permanent setting. Distraction changes what the dog notices. Find those levels on a long line, on an ordinary day, when nothing is at stake.

Step Three
Conditioning, at his level, on commands he already owns

Start with come. Bump at his working level, say Come, back up, pay him. Then sit, down, and heel. Three clean repetitions in a row and you can move on — the rule of three. Take as many sessions as the dog takes. What matters is that when you are finished he is not guessing.

Step Four
Application: no, bump, tug

NO — BUMP — TUG. Same order, same voice, every single time, until the response is clean and immediate.

Then the leash comes out of the sequence and it is just no and the bump. Then, in time, it is just the word. That is the prize.

Step Five
Proof it on a long line

You do not find out what you have until the dog thinks he is free. Fifty feet of check cord, an open field, and every distraction you can arrange. Learn what the dog does around real distractions on a rope you can step on, not on a road you cannot.

Now the part that is mine: the five, and the silence

Everything up to here you can get from any competent remote-collar man. This next part is thirty-five years of my own, and it is where I part company with most of the field.

  1. Running out into the street. The storm door, the gate, the truck door.
  2. Counter-surfing. A ninety-pound Lab can pull boiling water down on himself or a child.
  3. Jumping on people. Cute at twelve pounds; dangerous at eighty.
  4. Chewing the wrong things. A live extension cord can mean electrocution or fire.
  5. Biting and mouthing the kids. What the family calls playing is rehearsal, and it has to stop.
THE DOGGY LIFE MAXIM:
DANGEROUS FOR YOU OR ANOTHER — LIGHTNING BOLT FROM GOD STRIKES.

On these five, you say nothing. Not a word. Not no. Not his name. The consequence is married to the act, not to the person standing nearby.

Understand the fence around this. The Maxim applies to the five and to nothing else. It comes after full conditioning, never before. Sit and heel and place and every other command in the book get taught the patient way, with a word and a reward and ten thousand repetitions.

Where I Stand

There is honest disagreement in my field. The American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior and a lot of good trainers favor reward-based methods and would rather no aversive ever be used.8 I use a mountain of positive reinforcement myself, every day, on every dog that comes through here.9 But after thirty-five years I have not found another honest way to be standing beside a dog who is four hundred yards away and one stride from a road, or from a rattlesnake.10 Used on a finished foundation, at the dog's own level, with clean timing, this collar is the closest thing I own to being in two places at once.

Gus never got that. Eleven months of a good dog, ended by four inches of open door and a voice that could not reach him. He is the reason this page exists.

John's field note. Before you blame the collar, check three things in this order: is it charged, is it fitted, and did you actually condition the dog. Ninety percent of the “my e-collar does not work” calls I get die right there on the first two.

John's Picks — training gear I use

As an Amazon Associate, Hunters Creek Retrievers earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

A note from John: I am not a veterinarian. This reflects the sources below and thirty-five years of raising and training Labradors on the Gulf Coast. Read the sources, do your own homework, and make the call that is right for your dog.

Sources

  1. Cleveland Clinic — Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation (TENS).
  2. GearJunkie — How and Why to Train Your Dog With an Electronic Collar.
  3. Ed Frawley / Leerburg — The Evolution of Working Levels in Remote Collar Training.
  4. Dogtra 280C product specifications.
  5. Canine Revolution Dog Training — How to Properly Fit and Use a Dog E-Collar.
  6. Sporting Dog Pro — Pressure Necrosis from Dog Collar Misuse.
  7. Dogtra — How to Choose the Right E-Collar Level for Your Dog.
  8. American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior — Position Statement on Humane Dog Training.
  9. American Kennel Club — Positive Reinforcement Dog Training.
  10. Texas Veterinary Medical Foundation — Texas Snakebites on Pets.
  11. Garrett Wing / DIY K9 — Zero to Hero / FHVLE progression.
  12. E-Collar Training For Beginners three-step series.
Top Dog Training USA

In-home and board-and-train e-collar programs

Greater Houston · Katy · Sealy · Cypress