A post rolled across Facebook last week — “Did you know this about glyphosate?” — three faces in a row on a video call, a man named Morley Robbins and a white-haired lady from MIT named Stephanie Seneff, telling six thousand people that glyphosate is “forcing a lack of copper” while iron piles up in the tissue of people all over the planet. Under it a fellow had pasted in a Google answer about copper. Below him, a man was hollering about a Swiss company in 1778, and below him a lady was explaining how to remove the leaves from a tea bag. That is the internet: one nugget of gold sitting in a creek bed full of mud. So the nugget got picked up, carried to the bench, and put under a real light. Here is what it is made of.
— RACHEL CARSON, 1963
· · ·
“My people are destroyed for lack of knowledge.”
— HOSEA 4:6
Start with the picture. Chelation comes from the Greek word for claw. A chelator is a molecule with pincers. It swims through soil water or a plant’s sap or a dog’s gut, finds a loose mineral — copper, manganese, iron, zinc, calcium, magnesium — clamps on, and will not let go. The mineral is still there. It is simply handcuffed. The root cannot drink it, the enzyme cannot use it, the body cannot borrow it. Now hold that picture and read the next paragraph.
It was a boiler cleaner before it was a weed killer
In 1961 a chemical outfit named Stauffer filed a patent on a family of phosphonic-acid compounds, and the government granted it in 1964. The patent does not mention weeds. It brags about “chelation of ferric ions” and how one mole of it will “chelate 4 mole of calcium ions” — language written for men who scrub scale out of pipes and boilers.1 Glyphosate belongs to that family of molecules. Its first job description was grab metal.
Ten years later Monsanto put the same claw on the market under the name Roundup, because it turned out a molecule that handcuffs manganese also chokes an enzyme every green plant needs to live. Then in 1996 came “Roundup Ready” seed, engineered to survive a bath in it, and the spraying went from a squirt to a flood. Since 1974 the world has poured out roughly 8.6 billion kilograms of glyphosate — 1.6 billion of it on American ground — and global use is up almost fifteen-fold since those seeds arrived. Two-thirds of all the glyphosate ever sprayed in this country went down in the last ten years of that study.2 Picture a rain gauge that has never once been emptied.
Here is the kicker, and it is not from some blogger in a tinfoil hat. In 2010 Monsanto itself was granted a patent on glyphosate as an antimicrobial — a way to inhibit the growth of parasites and pathogens by choking the same enzyme pathway that bacteria use.3 Read that twice. The company that sells it as a weed killer also patented it as a germ killer. Your dog’s gut is a barn full of bacteria that have to be alive for him to digest a meal. Roundup’s own paperwork says it goes after bacteria.
How glyphosate chelates minerals in the field
The Facebook post said glyphosate handcuffs copper, iron, magnesium, and zinc in the soil and the plant. The peer-reviewed literature says the same thing in longer words. A 2018 review in Environmental Science and Pollution Research calls glyphosate flat out “a chelating agent that binds macro- and micronutrients, essential for many plant processes and pathogen resistance,” forming stable complexes with calcium, magnesium, manganese, and iron.4 Turkish agronomists sprayed soybeans with a light drift of it — a fraction of the label rate, the amount a neighbor’s field would catch on a breezy morning — and the beans that came off those plants carried significantly less calcium, magnesium, iron, and manganese, which the authors pinned on glyphosate “binding and thus immobilizing them.”5 Not killed. Robbed. The bean looks like a bean. It is a lighter bean.
Now walk that bean down the chain. It gets crushed into soybean meal. The meal goes into a forty-pound sack of kibble. The kibble goes into a bowl. The claw rides along, because glyphosate does not evaporate on the way to the feed mill. Cornell scientists tested eighteen commercial dog and cat foods off the shelf in 2018 and found glyphosate in every one, at roughly 80 to 2,000 micrograms per kilogram — and the bag labeled GMO-free had more of it than several of the conventional bags.6 The independent lab that tests people for glyphosate ran the same test on pets and found dogs averaging 15.8 parts per billion in their urine — thirty-two times the human average — with grain-free kibble the worst of the bunch and raw-fed dogs showing “virtually no detectable glyphosate.”7 The dogs eating what God made are clean. The dogs eating what a marketing department made are carrying thirty-two times their owner’s load.
Nor are the people. A JAMA study out of San Diego followed the same hundred folks for twenty-three years: in the mid-nineties twelve percent of them had glyphosate in their urine; by 2016 seventy percent did, and the average level had climbed thirteen-fold.8 The doctor who ran it said most people “are unaware that they are consuming them through their diet.” You are not spraying it. You are eating it. So is the dog.
Copper, and the cost of losing it
The post leaned hard on copper, so let the government say what copper is for. The National Institutes of Health lists it as the working part of enzymes that run “energy production, iron metabolism, neuropeptide activation, connective tissue synthesis, and neurotransmitter synthesis,” along with immune function and brain development. Run short and the list reads: anemia, connective tissue disorders, osteoporosis and other bone defects, ataxia, and increased risk of infection.9 Copper is the rivet in the collagen. Pull rivets and the joints get loose. The Weston A. Price Foundation piece the Facebook commenter leaned on makes exactly that point about glyphosate and collagen.10
The fellow on the video, Morley Robbins, says a lack of copper leads to iron piling up in the tissue and that this “has been known for 90+ years.” Checked. It has. In 1928 four scientists at the University of Wisconsin — Hart, Steenbock, Waddell, and Elvehjem — raised rats on nothing but whole milk until they went anemic, then tried to cure them with iron. Iron alone did nothing. The moment they added a trace of copper, the rats built hemoglobin and came back.18 Ninety-eight years ago, in a rat lab in Madison, the point was settled: iron is the brick, copper is the mason, and a pile of bricks with no mason is not a wall. It is a pile. That is what “iron accumulation” means — iron the body cannot lay, stacking up where it does harm. Robbins is right on the history. Where he goes after that — the free guide, the protocol, the book — is the part where a man keeps one hand on his wallet, and the comment section, a few paragraphs down, will tell you why.
Copper is one drawer. The drawer science has yanked open widest is manganese. Glyphosate’s whole herbicidal trick works by choking an enzyme that runs on manganese. Two researchers — one of them Stephanie Seneff of MIT, the same white-haired lady on that video — laid out in 2015 how a chemical that handcuffs manganese in the plant will keep handcuffing it in the gut, starving the Lactobacillus that live on manganese and, downstream, the manganese-dependent enzymes that guard the brain.11 Same claw, different drawer.
Now, a warning before anybody grabs the pliers. Yesterday’s post — Copper in the Water Bowl? Keep Your Change — laid out why the Labrador, of all breeds, is the last dog on earth you want to dose with extra copper; their livers hoard it. The answer to a thief in the mineral drawer is not to buy more minerals and leave the door unlocked. The answer is to throw the thief out of the house. Less poison in the bowl beats more pennies in the water every day of the week.
The comment section wrote the second half
Scroll down under that post and you will find every mistake a well-meaning person can make with a mineral, stacked up like feed sacks on a pallet. One lady, Joni, had it half right: copper and zinc ride a seesaw, and when one goes up the other goes down. The government agrees with her — fifty milligrams of zinc a day for a few weeks will shut the door on copper absorption, and the legal ceiling for a grown man is forty.15 So every fellow shoveling zinc lozenges since 2020 has been quietly starving his copper. She was right. Then a man named Terry answered her by telling everybody to drop “copper cubes” and “zinc cubes” in their big water containers, one each, because it “kills all bacteria” and “provides pure copper.” That is the penny in the dog bowl again, wearing a bigger hat. Read yesterday’s post before you put a slug of metal in anything a Labrador drinks.
Then Stuart wrote in that his whole house is plumbed in copper, so he is in no danger of running short. Stuart has a point, and the EPA has a number for it: copper “enters drinking water primarily through plumbing materials,” and the federal action level is 1.3 parts per million — the line past which a water system has to start treating its pipes so they quit dissolving into your coffee.16 So yes, Stuart, you are getting copper from the pipe. You are also getting whatever else the pipe sheds, in whatever dose the water chemistry decides, and the dog drinking out of the same tap in a copper-hoarding breed is the one who pays for it first. Minerals from a pipe are not nutrition. They are plumbing.
A lady named Candice said the whole thing “gives another meaning” to the kingdom of iron and clay “in the book of Revelation.” Bless her heart, that is Daniel, chapter two — Nebuchadnezzar’s statue with feet of iron mixed with clay, which “shall not cleave one to another.” Right picture, wrong book. Iron that will not hold to what it is mixed with is a fair description of a mineral sitting in a cell with a claw around it. Get the citation right, though, or the man with the search bar gets to dismiss the whole thought.
The sharpest question on the page came from a fellow named Leon: was the sample taken from a normal field or from a spill? The page owner answered, “I’m not sure.” That is the honest answer, and it is why the studies in the footnotes above were sprayed at drift rates — the amount a neighbor’s field catches on a breezy morning — and off-the-shelf sacks of kibble, not spill sites. Leon asked the right question. Now he has the answer.
Then there is Eamonn, an Irish farmer with thirty-five thumbs-up under his name. He sprays copper sulphate and washing soda on his potatoes to stop blight, the way his people have for a hundred years, and his potato tops came through the summer drought green and standing. He said so at an organic farm walk, and a speaker from a government-funded advisory board told him, in front of everybody: “You can’t be using that sort of stuff on plants, you’re not a chemist and have no idea how to mix it or no scientific degree.” Then the same man told him he could buy it premixed from a chemical company in Holland — at ten times the price. Eamonn did not answer him. He did not have to. Copper sulphate on a crop is the oldest fungicide on earth: a French botanist named Millardet worked it out in the 1880s in the vineyards of Bordeaux, it was the first fungicide ever used at scale anywhere in the world, it is still what beats the same potato blight that starved a million Irishmen in the 1840s, and it is approved for organic farming today because lime and copper sulphate occur in nature.17 So a government man stood on Irish soil and told an Irish farmer he needed a degree to fight the blight. Seventeen years of standing in courtrooms without a law license teaches a man exactly what that speech is. It is not about safety. It is about who gets paid. The fellow with the degree wanted Eamonn buying from Holland, and Eamonn wanted potatoes. Eamonn has potatoes.
Here is what nobody in that thread noticed. Read the replies from the page itself. Every one of them — to Joni, to Stuart, to Leon, to a man named Yag, to a lady named Naomi — ends the same way: “Have you started the Root Cause Protocol? I’ll send you the FREE RCP Starter Guide. Diane.” A dozen people asking a dozen different questions and getting the same coupon. Under the video itself the top comment is a lady thanking “Morely” because his frozen shoulder story fixed her frozen shoulder, and under her a man explaining that heavy metals are “for the nano dust to build with.” That is the testimonial and the crank, side by side, which is exactly how the page likes it — one makes you trust, the other makes you feel smart by comparison, and both keep you scrolling toward the guide. That is not a health page. That is a funnel with a glyphosate video for a front door, and the comment section is the waiting room.
The Ad That Diagnosed Your Dog laid out how that machine works; this is the same machine in a different hat. The glyphosate science is real. The people selling you the cure for it are the same kind of people who sold you the disease. Read the footnotes, not the coupon.
The company already told you what it thinks
In 2015 the World Health Organization’s cancer agency put glyphosate in Group 2A, “probably carcinogenic to humans.”12 Bayer, which bought Monsanto, paid roughly ten billion dollars to settle most of 125,000 lawsuits, set aside billions more, and announced it would pull glyphosate out of every Roundup sold to homeowners by 2023 — while insisting, straight-faced, the move was “exclusively geared at managing litigation risk and not because of any safety concerns.”13 Sure. And I quit drinking because of the price of beer. A company does not write a ten-billion-dollar check for a product it believes is harmless. It keeps selling it to the farms, though. The farms grow the corn. The corn goes into the kibble. Follow the sack.
If your weed killer was invented to clean a boiler, you might be eating plumbing supplies.
What to do about it, in a kennel or a kitchen
The dogs on this place eat real food — meat, bone, and organ, the way God made it, sourced from butchers within an hour of here who would otherwise throw it away — and that is no fad; it is thirty-five years of watching what holds up. The lab numbers above are simply the thermometer confirming what the eye already knew: the raw-fed dog runs clean, the kibble dog runs dirty. If you cannot go all the way, go part of the way. Read the bag. Corn, soy, wheat, oats, peas, and lentils are the crops that get the heaviest bath — oats, wheat, barley, and beans get sprayed right before harvest to kill and dry the crop for the combine14 — and “grain-free” usually means the peas and lentils moved in where the corn moved out, which is why the grain-free bags tested worst. Organic feed, or meat from an animal that never saw a sprayed field, is the only label that means anything on this subject. Do not spray Roundup where the dog walks and licks his feet. (Little Dolly, with the yellow Lab’s front paws in the bathroom sink: “Mommy said wash your hands before supper. He’s got four.”) Your dog will thank you by living longer, and you might, too.
The fellow on Facebook who pasted the Google answer was right. The man yelling about 1778 was not. Learn to tell the difference, because the Lord did not say His people were destroyed for lack of chemicals. He said for lack of knowledge — and the next words out of Hosea’s mouth are “because thou hast rejected knowledge.” Those people did not lack it. They had it and rolled on by, same as a thumb on a Facebook feed.
Glyphosate is a claw. It was patented to grab metal before it ever killed a weed, and it is still grabbing metal in the soil, the crop, the sack, and the dog. You cannot out-supplement a thief. Get the thief out of the bowl — real meat, real bone, organic where you can — and the minerals take care of themselves. Raw-fed dogs tested clean. That is the whole sermon. “Be thou diligent to know the state of thy flocks” — Proverbs 27:23.
A Lab who was fed from the sack
Went dull in the coat and the back;
The claw in the peas
Had stolen his ease —
Raw bone and raw liver brought him back.
— original, Hunters Creek
Keep reading: Copper in the Water Bowl? Keep Your Change · Ninety Centuries of Real Milk · Fast One Day a Week: The Science of Autophagy · The Ad That Diagnosed Your Dog
A note from John: I am not a veterinarian, and I am not a chemist. Every claim above is footnoted to a patent, a peer-reviewed paper, or a government fact sheet you can read yourself. Do your own homework, read the bag, and if you change what your dog eats, do it over a week or two so his gut can catch up. The rest is between you, your dog, and the God who made them both.
Sources
[1] U.S. Patent 3,160,632, “Aminomethylenephosphinic acids, salts thereof, and process for their production,” assigned to Stauffer Chemical Co., filed January 30, 1961, granted December 8, 1964 — describes the compounds’ “chelation of ferric ions” and calcium-chelating capacity. Read patent . Monsanto scientists (Swarthout, Bleeke & Vicini, Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 2018) dispute that glyphosate by name was patented as a chelator; the Stauffer patent covers the phosphonic-acid family to which glyphosate belongs.
[2] Benbrook, C. M. (2016). “Trends in glyphosate herbicide use in the United States and globally.” Environmental Sciences Europe, 28:3 — 8.6 billion kg globally and over 1.6 billion kg in the U.S. since 1974; global use up almost 15-fold since Roundup Ready crops (1996); two-thirds of all U.S. glyphosate applied in the last ten years of the study period. doi:10.1186/s12302-016-0070-0.
[3] U.S. Patent 7,771,736 B2, “Glyphosate formulations and their use for the inhibition of 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase,” Monsanto Technology LLC, granted August 10, 2010 — claims glyphosate to inhibit the growth of pathogenic microorganisms and parasites via the shikimate pathway. Read patent .
[4] Mertens, M., Höss, S., Neumann, G., Afzal, J., & Reichenbecher, W. (2018). “Glyphosate, a chelating agent—relevant for ecological risk assessment?” Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 25(6), 5298–5317. doi:10.1007/s11356-017-1080-1.
[5] Çakmak, I., Yazıcı, A., Tutuş, Y., & Öztürk, L. (2009). “Glyphosate reduced seed and leaf concentrations of calcium, manganese, magnesium, and iron in non-glyphosate resistant soybean.” European Journal of Agronomy, 31(3), 114–119 — drift-level doses (0.06–1.2% of label rate) significantly reduced seed Ca, Mg, Fe and Mn; Cu and Zn were unchanged in that study.
[6] Zhao, J., Pacenka, S., Wu, J., Richards, B. K., Steenhuis, T., Simpson, K., & Hay, A. G. (2018). “Detection of glyphosate residues in companion animal feeds.” Environmental Pollution, 243, 1113–1118; Cornell Chronicle, Oct. 24, 2018 — 18 pet foods, glyphosate in all, ~80–2,000 µg/kg; the GMO-free product exceeded several conventional feeds. The authors put the median dog’s exposure at 0.7% of the U.S. human limit.
[7] Health Research Institute (HRI Labs) pet glyphosate testing, reported by Hemopet / Dr. W. Jean Dodds, “Glyphosate and Your Companion Pets” — dogs averaging 15.8 ppb urinary glyphosate, 32× the human average; raw-fed dogs “virtually no detectable glyphosate”; grain-free kibble highest. HRI’s Dr. John Fagan, quoted by EcoWatch (2019), reported an earlier pilot in which dogs’ levels ran on average 50× people’s; the 32× figure is HRI’s later, larger sample. hemopet.org.
[8] Mills, P. J., Kania-Korwel, I., Fagan, J., McEvoy, L. K., & Laughlin, G. A. (2017). “Excretion of the Herbicide Glyphosate in Older Adults Between 1993 and 2016.” JAMA, 318(16), 1610–1611 — 100 participants; detectable glyphosate rose from 12% of the cohort (1993–1996) to 70% (2014–2016); mean level 0.024 to 0.314 µg/L. UC San Diego release, Oct. 24, 2017.
[9] National Institutes of Health, Office of Dietary Supplements, “Copper — Fact Sheet for Health Professionals.” NIH Copper Fact Sheet .
[10] Carlin, M., “Side Effects of Glyphosate in Food,” The Weston A. Price Foundation (updated Jan. 2025) — glyphosate’s effects on fermentation and collagen; the source cited in the Facebook comment. westonaprice.org.
[11] Samsel, A., & Seneff, S. (2015). “Glyphosate, pathways to modern diseases III: Manganese, neurological diseases, and associated pathologies.” Surgical Neurology International, 6:45. doi:10.4103/2152-7806.153876.
[12] International Agency for Research on Cancer, IARC Monographs Vol. 112, March 2015 — glyphosate classified Group 2A, “probably carcinogenic to humans.” iarc.who.int.
[13] Erickson, B. E., “Bayer to end glyphosate sales to US consumers,” Chemical & Engineering News, 99(29), July 2021 — residential glyphosate products withdrawn by 2023; nearly $10 billion settlement covering ~75% of 125,000+ suits, $4.5 billion more set aside; CEO Werner Baumann: “exclusively geared at managing litigation risk and not because of any safety concerns.”
[14] Environmental Working Group, “Breakfast With a Dose of Roundup?” Aug. 14, 2018 — glyphosate detected in 43 of 45 conventional oat-product samples; “increasingly, glyphosate is also sprayed just before harvest on wheat, barley, oats and beans that are not genetically engineered. Glyphosate kills the crop, drying it out so that it can be harvested sooner.” ewg.org/research/breakfast-dose-roundup.
[15] National Institutes of Health, Office of Dietary Supplements, “Zinc — Fact Sheet for Health Professionals” — “If used for weeks, doses of 50 mg zinc or more… can interfere with copper absorption”; Tolerable Upper Intake Level for adults, 40 mg/day. NIH Zinc Fact Sheet .
[16] U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Lead and Copper Rule — copper action level 1.3 ppm; “lead and copper enter drinking water primarily through plumbing materials.” EPA Lead and Copper Rule .
[17] Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Bordeaux mixture” — hydrated lime, copper sulfate and water, developed by Pierre-Marie-Alexis Millardet (discovered 1882, in use 1888) against vine downy mildew; “the first fungicide to receive large-scale use the world over”; still used against potato blight; Burgundy mixture substitutes sodium carbonate (washing soda) for the lime. McGill University Office for Science and Society, “What is Bordeaux Mixture?” — permitted in organic farming because “both lime and copper sulphate occur in nature.”
[18] Hart, E. B., Steenbock, H., Waddell, J., & Elvehjem, C. A. (1928). “Iron in nutrition. VII. Copper as a supplement to iron for hemoglobin building in the rat.” Journal of Biological Chemistry, 77 — rats made anemic on a whole-milk diet did not recover on iron alone; adding copper restored hemoglobin. See also JBC Classics, “The Role of Copper in Anemia: the Work of Edwin B. Hart.”