On Christmas Eve of 2023, a licensed real-estate agent in Ohio named Ann Logan, a woman thirteen hundred (1,300) miles away who has never been my client, never purchased a dog from me, never set foot on my property, and who admitted to me in writing, "We have NEVER done business, we don't know each other," took the time out of her holiday to come onto my business page and post this about my life's work: "Breeding multiple dogs like a factory #puppymill Using animals for financial greed. You're disgusting."
Consider the sheer boldness of that. For a woman who makes her living in real estate to ride onto a breeder's page in another state and appoint herself its moral judge is a little like my riding onto her property listings to lecture her that every wood-framed house she sells cost a stand of timber and a cloud of carbon, and asking how she escapes the self-loathing of being so disgusting. I would never presume to do such a thing, because I do not know her business, and she plainly did not know mine. When I answered her with an honest public review of her professionalism, she reported me to the police for harassment; the matter was reviewed by the prosecutor and closed. Thirty-five years of raising championship Labs, of dogs placed with veterans through the Lone Survivor Foundation and with cancer families through the Ronald McDonald House, and a stranger reduced it all to a hashtag on Christmas Eve.
I tell that story not for sympathy, but because Ann Logan is the "adopt don't shop" movement distilled to a single post: absolute confidence, zero knowledge, and a slogan doing the work that thought should be doing.
The Slogan Shames, and It Is Built on Two Lies
I am not the only one who sees it. Dr. Tannetje' Crocker, a veterinarian writing in the trade journal dvm360, describes new pet owners who "speak in an apologetic tone" when they admit they bought from a breeder, as though they had confessed to something shameful. She lays out the two false premises the whole campaign rests on: the first, that "all rescue animals will be put to sleep unless you go out right now and save one," and the second, that "all breeders are bad people" running puppy mills. Neither is true, and Dr. Crocker calls the use of the hashtag "to promote an intolerant behavior toward certain pets" exactly what it is, aggravating. Her advice is the sensible replacement for the slogan: "Pick your next pet responsibly."
That is a standard I have met for over three decades, and gladly.
The Hypocrisy Behind the Slogan
Here is the part the Ann Logans of the world never examine. Much of the "rescue" world is a business, and a business needs inventory to survive. So where does the inventory come from? Three places, and none of them is the story printed on the donation envelope. First, they buy it: the Washington Post documented "rescues" bidding on the very commercial-auction dogs they publicly condemn, paying breeders at those auctions and reselling the same dogs as rescues. Second, they import it: the retail-rescue trade hauls dogs in from Mexico and from overseas by the tens of thousands to keep the adoption floor stocked, so many, from so many countries, that in 2021 the Centers for Disease Control suspended dog imports from more than one hundred (100) nations after that pipeline began carrying disease across our borders along with the dogs. Third, when buying and importing are not enough, they take it: dogs seized in raids on breeders' kennels are put up for adoption, the seizure quietly recast as a rescue.
This is neither new nor fringe. Reporting for ABC's 20/20, John Stossel documented the same abuse years ago, telling viewers: "I thought they were heroic animal rescuers, but some animal owners say they act like petty tyrants, confiscating animals that aren't in trouble. The SPCAs are not police agencies, but they are given the authority to act like it. Animal owners tell us SPCAs abuse their power to steal people's animals."
And the money is very real. In more recent reporting, Stossel notes that the ASPCA takes in more than three hundred million dollars ($300 million) a year while directing only about two percent (2%) of it to the shelters whose imagery fills its fundraising, with its chief executive paid more than one million dollars ($1.2 million) a year; he further notes that after California banned pet-store sales, puppy scams jumped three hundred fifty percent (350%) and ninety-five percent (95%) of the affected stores closed, driving buyers straight to the unverified sellers the ban was supposed to stop.
The slogan that brands every breeder a greedy villain is often chanted by operations that are themselves moving dogs for money, and sourcing them in ways that would horrify the very people writing the checks. Before anyone accepts a slogan as gospel, two questions are worth asking that the slogan never answers: who profits, and where did this dog actually come from?
The Real Reasons to Buy From a Responsible Breeder
Set the slogans aside and look at what a responsible breeder actually gives a family. The American Kennel Club puts it plainly, and every point matches how I have run Hunters Creek for thirty-five (35) years.
You get predictability. With a well-bred dog you know, in the AKC's words, "whether you are getting a breed that exemplifies what you want from a dog," a dog that is "physically and temperamentally sound," instead of gambling on the unknown history, size, and temperament of an animal nobody can vouch for. For a family choosing a service dog, a therapy dog, or a companion for small children, that predictability is not a luxury; it is the whole ballgame.
You get health that was engineered, not hoped for. Responsible breeders test their breeding pairs for the genetic diseases that plague a breed, and Dr. Crocker lists it among the marks of a good breeder: they "test for genetic mutations" and breed for sound behavior. In my kennel that means hips and elbows cleared through OFA, eyes certified, the DNA markers checked, and a two-year health guarantee behind every puppy. That bargain dog from an untested pair can become a four-to-six-thousand-dollar ($4,000 to $6,000) hip surgery and a lifetime of pain; the testing is the difference.
You get a head start. My puppies are raised in my home, started days after birth with Early Neurological Stimulation, and carried through a Puppy Head Start foundation before they ever go to a family. The AKC counts early socialization and foundational care among the core reasons a responsible breeder is worth it, and I have had championship pups delivering retrieves to hand by sixteen (16) weeks because of it.
You get a match, not a transaction. A responsible breeder watches a litter for weeks and steers each family to the puppy "most likely to fit best into your life." I have turned families toward an older dog, and even toward a rescue, when that was the better fit. That is the opposite of a factory.
And you get a person for the life of the dog. The AKC notes that responsible breeders "will always be ready to take back or re-home any dog they produced," and that they serve as "knowledgeable mentors after you take your puppy home." No Hunters Creek dog has ever needed a shelter, because the breeder answers the phone for the life of the dog. That, too, is the opposite of contributing to the very homeless-pet problem the slogan blames on us.
Adopt, or Buy Responsibly, but Decide for Yourself
None of this is a shot at rescue done right, or at the good family that adopts the right dog for their life. Adopt if that is the right fit; buy from a reputable breeder if that is the right fit. What I will not accept, and what no family should accept, is a stranger with an agenda deciding for them, or shaming them into an apologetic tone for making a sound, loving, responsible choice. Pick your next dog responsibly, do your homework, ask the breeder every hard question you can think of, and let the truth, not a hashtag, guide you home.
Sources
[1] American Kennel Club — "Why Buy From a Responsible Breeder?" — AKC
[2] Dr. Tannetje' Crocker, DVM — "'Adopt don't shop'—marketing genius or shaming slogan?" — dvm360 — dvm360
[3] The Washington Post — "How some rescue dogs come from breeders at commercial auctions" — Washington Post
[4] CBS News Colorado — investigations into retail rescue revenue and puppy importing/disease — CBS News
[5] U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention — "Frequently Asked Questions on Dog Importations" — CDC
[6] Associated Press — "The Latest: Dogs seized from breeder's home nearing adoption" — Associated Press / Yahoo
[7] John Stossel — "Banning Pet Sales" — John Stossel
[8] John Stossel / ABC 20/20 — segment on SPCA animal seizures, as recounted by TheDogPlace.org — TheDogPlace.org
This article reflects my own views and experience as a Labrador breeder, and my own account of a documented public exchange. Quoted statements are reproduced from public posts and from correspondence in my possession.